Eyal Erlich may still be in the early stages of his recording career, but with four recent singles—“All in All,” “Jenny,” “Already In,” and “I Wish I Knew”—the singer-songwriter demonstrates why his name is quickly finding traction on streaming platforms and beyond. Each track presents a different facet of his artistry: thoughtful lyricism, soulful melodies, and a delivery that feels as authentic as it is inviting. It’s a combination that positions him as one of the more compelling new voices in the independent scene, with the potential to break out on a much larger scale.
“All in All” is the most understated of the four, but also one of the most resonant. Built on an acoustic foundation and carried by Erlich’s calm vocal tone, the song feels intimate and conversational. Rather than reaching for grand statements, Erlich leans into quiet sincerity, letting the listener draw close. It’s the kind of track that thrives on repeat plays, growing deeper with each listen. In today’s streaming-driven market, where playlist appeal often determines a song’s longevity, “All in All” has the kind of subtle, steady charm that could easily earn a place on acoustic or singer-songwriter curated lists.
“Jenny” moves into more narrative territory, recalling the classic storytelling tradition of artists like James Taylor or Cat Stevens. The lyrics focus on a figure from the past—Jenny—yet the lack of specific detail makes the song resonate universally, allowing listeners to graft their own memories and associations onto the name. Musically, the track maintains Erlich’s signature restraint, giving his vocals space to carry the emotional weight. The result is one of his most haunting releases to date, a song that underscores his ability to connect with listeners through relatability and mood rather than spectacle.
With “Already In,” Erlich shows a brighter side of his repertoire. More upbeat in some sections, than the previous singles, the track captures the exhilaration of surrendering fully to love or experience. Its tempo and hopeful phrasing mark a shift in tone, demonstrating his versatility. Importantly, “Already In” hints at Erlich’s potential crossover appeal; the song feels radio-ready, capable of appealing not only to core singer-songwriter fans but also to mainstream pop listeners looking for an uplifting anthem.
Closing the set is “I Wish I Knew,” perhaps the most vulnerable of the four. The title itself conveys uncertainty, and the song delivers exactly that—a meditation on regret, longing, and the unanswered questions that follow us through life. Erlich’s vocals here are understated but powerful, drawing strength from their fragility. In an era where authenticity is prized as much as technical perfection, “I Wish I Knew” lands as one of his most impactful tracks, one that could resonate strongly in sync opportunities or late-night radio slots.
Together, these songs illustrate an artist on the cusp of something bigger. Eyal Erlich isn’t reinventing the singer-songwriter wheel, but he doesn’t need to. What he offers is a refreshing combination of honesty, craft, and emotional depth that feels increasingly rare in a crowded landscape. With his debut album on the horizon and growing streaming numbers signaling strong listener engagement, Erlich is poised to make 2025 a breakthrough year.
–James Dupree
